Annotating post-mortem control samples with thanatome

Introduction

Post-mortem tissue from GTEx (GTEx Consortium 2020) and similar resources is the usual “normal” control when a tumour cohort has no adjacent normal tissue. Those donors died in different ways, which GTEx records with the four-point Hardy scale of the circumstances of death (Hardy et al. 1985): on a ventilator in intensive care (Hardy scale 0), suddenly (Hardy 1-2) or after a slow illness (Hardy 3-4), and their organs were collected hours after death. Death and post-mortem ischemia leave transcriptional traces (Ferreira et al. 2018; Pozhitkov et al. 2017), and GTEx samples also carry technical contamination from neighbouring tissues (Nieuwenhuis et al. 2020). thanatome carries consensus transcriptional signatures of those processes, derived from GTEx v8 across ten tissues, and uses them to annotate every sample of a cohort before any downstream analysis:

  • ventilator: ventilated versus non-ventilated donors; seen from outside GTEx it is the axis perfused versus post-mortem;
  • agony: slow versus fast deaths among non-ventilated donors;
  • ischemia, not a third axis but the component of the ventilator axis sensitive to post-mortem ischemic time, meaningful among perfused donors only.

For each sample the package returns a score per axis, a position scaled between the two poles of the reference tissue, a state label and technical flags. The user can then plot the cohort, select samples with explicit criteria, or carry the scores into a design matrix.

How this differs from existing tools: sva (Leek et al. 2012) and RUVSeq (Risso et al. 2014) estimate unwanted variation from the data at hand without saying what it is; limma::removeBatchEffect() removes a known covariate. thanatome supplies the covariate with a biological name, anchored to GTEx references, and reports what each sample looks like before any adjustment. The post-mortem interval predictors of Ferreira et al. (2018) estimate ischemic time; here ischemic time is one component of a wider description of the donor’s death.

Installation

if (!requireNamespace("BiocManager", quietly = TRUE)) {
    install.packages("BiocManager")
}
BiocManager::install("thanatome")

Scoring a cohort

The example data are 74 GTEx v8 ovary controls and 40 TCGA-OV primary tumours from recount3, with raw counts of the signature genes, the full library size of each sample and the Hardy scale of each donor. The controls are scored first; the tumours enter later, when the differential expression is repeated with different control subsets.

suppressPackageStartupMessages({
    library(thanatome)
    library(SummarizedExperiment)
})
data(thanatome_example)
thanatome_example
#> class: SummarizedExperiment 
#> dim: 1663 114 
#> metadata(2): tissue source
#> assays(1): counts
#> rownames(1663): ENSG00000237973 ENSG00000187608 ... ENSG00000228986
#>   ENSG00000235649
#> rowData names(1): symbol
#> colnames(114): GTEX-145LS-2326-SM-5TDCY GTEX-1PIEJ-1626-SM-E6CP9 ...
#>   TCGA-25-1313-01A-01R-1565-13 TCGA-29-1785-01A-01R-1567-13
#> colData names(6): group lib_size ... ischemic_time rin
ctl <- thanatome_example[, thanatome_example$group == "control"]
table(hardy = ctl$hardy)
#> hardy
#>  0  1  2  3  4 
#> 45  6 10  6  7

A reference of the same tissue is mandatory: the scores are means of per-gene z-scores, and a sample has no z-score on its own. The package carries the reference of ten GTEx tissues, built from recount3 counts (Wilks et al. 2021); the example data come from recount3 too, so they match. For data quantified with another pipeline, pass your own cohort as reference: scores are rank-stable across pipelines but positions are not.

sc <- thanatome_score(ctl, reference = "ovary")
cols <- c("ventilator", "ischemia", "agony",
    "position_ventilator", "position_agony", "state")
sc[1:5, cols]
#> DataFrame with 5 rows and 6 columns
#>                          ventilator  ischemia     agony position_ventilator
#>                           <numeric> <numeric> <numeric>           <numeric>
#> GTEX-145LS-2326-SM-5TDCY  -0.359062  0.194642 -0.536718            1.070872
#> GTEX-1PIEJ-1626-SM-E6CP9  -0.136852  0.392311 -0.123320            0.631058
#> GTEX-11ZVC-1426-SM-5EGGA  -0.252840  0.113958 -0.437914            0.860630
#> GTEX-13X6H-1026-SM-5SIBE   0.260266  0.198291  0.515456           -0.154949
#> GTEX-WYBS-2426-SM-4ONDI   -0.281514  0.921718 -0.289596            0.917383
#>                          position_agony            state
#>                               <numeric>      <character>
#> GTEX-145LS-2326-SM-5TDCY     -0.1003801 postmortem_rapid
#> GTEX-1PIEJ-1626-SM-E6CP9      0.6331653 postmortem_agony
#> GTEX-11ZVC-1426-SM-5EGGA      0.0749413 postmortem_rapid
#> GTEX-13X6H-1026-SM-5SIBE      1.7666274         perfused
#> GTEX-WYBS-2426-SM-4ONDI       0.3381198 postmortem_rapid

Because the example carries the Hardy scale, the function reports as an internal check how well each score recovers the label. These GTEx samples entered the consensus, the references and the poles, so the figures below are in-sample; the out-of-sample figures (signatures derived without the tissue) are AUC 0.87-0.94 for ventilator and 0.69-0.90 for agony.

metadata(sc)$auc
#> ventilator      agony 
#>  0.9425287  0.8125000
metadata(sc)$state_agreement
#> [1] 0.7297297

The scaled position is 0 at the median of the ventilated donors of the reference tissue and 1 at the median of the non-ventilated ones (for agony, 0 = fast deaths, 1 = slow deaths). Values outside 0-1 are allowed: living tissue falls below 0 on the ventilator axis. For cohorts quantified or sequenced apart from GTEx, read such values as a direction, not a magnitude: in external datasets the side of the poles on which a cohort fell was stable, but its distance beyond them changed with the handling of the batch (see External cohorts in ?thanatome_score). For that reason, when x carries the whole, unfiltered transcriptome its samples are quantile-normalised to the reference by default (normalize); pass the counts before any filtering of lowly expressed genes. The example carries only the signature genes, so it is scored without normalisation.

Looking at the samples

plot_thanatome(sc, hardy = ctl$hardy)

plot_thanatome(sc, type = "ranked")

Selecting samples with explicit criteria

select_samples() applies intervals on the positions, a set of allowed state labels and the technical flags, and reports what was excluded and why. No criterion on the death axes is applied by default (technical flags are excluded unless flags = FALSE): in the analyses behind the package no subset of post-mortem controls was closer to surgical or living tissue than the full set except, slightly, the ventilated donors, and every exclusion costs power. The two presets correspond to the criteria the evidence supports as explicit choices, each with its cost documented in the help page. The agony interval applies only to non-perfused samples, since the agony axis is defined among non-ventilated donors; ventilated donors pass it.

sel <- select_samples(sc, agony = c(-Inf, 0.5))
sel$summary
#>          n       kept ventilator      agony   ischemia      state      flags 
#>         74         60          0         13          0          0          2
head(sel$excluded)
#> DataFrame with 6 rows and 2 columns
#>                   sample      reason
#>              <character> <character>
#> 1 GTEX-1PIEJ-1626-SM-E..       agony
#> 2 GTEX-11ZVC-1426-SM-5..       flags
#> 3 GTEX-1RDX4-0826-SM-E..       agony
#> 4 GTEX-X4EO-2426-SM-4Q..       agony
#> 5 GTEX-13OVJ-2426-SM-5..       agony
#> 6 GTEX-146FH-2526-SM-5..       agony
keep <- ctl[, sel$keep]
keep
#> class: SummarizedExperiment 
#> dim: 1663 60 
#> metadata(2): tissue source
#> assays(1): counts
#> rownames(1663): ENSG00000237973 ENSG00000187608 ... ENSG00000228986
#>   ENSG00000235649
#> rowData names(1): symbol
#> colnames(60): GTEX-145LS-2326-SM-5TDCY GTEX-13X6H-1026-SM-5SIBE ...
#>   GTEX-1OJC4-2026-SM-E6CQW GTEX-1H1CY-1926-SM-9WG7X
#> colData names(6): group lib_size ... ischemic_time rin

To keep the annotation with the counts, add_thanatome_score() returns the SummarizedExperiment itself with the score columns added to its colData and the score metadata in metadata(x)$thanatome; the columns then travel into DESeqDataSet, DGEList or design matrices built from it, and prefix avoids clashes with existing columns.

ctl_ann <- add_thanatome_score(ctl, reference = "ovary")
table(ctl_ann$state, hardy = ctl_ann$hardy)
#>                   hardy
#>                     0  1  2  3  4
#>   perfused         36  0  0  1  2
#>   postmortem_agony  5  1  2  3  2
#>   postmortem_rapid  4  5  8  2  3

Using the scores as covariates

The scores can enter a design matrix or limma::removeBatchEffect() as continuous covariates. Two cautions apply: the axes vary only among post-mortem samples, so in a tumour-versus-control design adjust within controls or keep the group term; and the adjustment centres the controls at their mean, not at the living pole.

cv <- death_covariates(sc)
#> death_covariates: adjust within post-mortem controls or keep the group term in the design; the adjustment centres controls at their mean, not at the living pole
head(cv)
#>                          ventilator        agony
#> GTEX-145LS-2326-SM-5TDCY -0.3262836 -0.474967737
#> GTEX-1PIEJ-1626-SM-E6CP9 -0.1040744 -0.061569710
#> GTEX-11ZVC-1426-SM-5EGGA -0.2200621 -0.376163321
#> GTEX-13X6H-1026-SM-5SIBE  0.2930436  0.577205933
#> GTEX-WYBS-2426-SM-4ONDI  -0.2487358 -0.227846062
#> GTEX-12WSK-1926-SM-5LZVK  0.3432129 -0.001652532
logcpm <- edgeR::cpm(assay(ctl),
    lib.size = ctl$lib_size, log = TRUE, prior.count = 1)
adjusted <- limma::removeBatchEffect(logcpm, covariates = cv,
    design = matrix(1, ncol(logcpm), 1))
dim(adjusted)
#> [1] 1663   74

The annotated object from add_thanatome_score() feeds the usual model formulas directly, for example to ask, within the controls, which genes follow the death axes, or to carry the axes into a DESeqDataSet:

design <- model.matrix(~ ventilator + agony, data = colData(ctl_ann))
head(design)
#>                          (Intercept) ventilator       agony
#> GTEX-145LS-2326-SM-5TDCY           1 -0.3590617 -0.53671796
#> GTEX-1PIEJ-1626-SM-E6CP9           1 -0.1368525 -0.12331993
#> GTEX-11ZVC-1426-SM-5EGGA           1 -0.2528402 -0.43791354
#> GTEX-13X6H-1026-SM-5SIBE           1  0.2602655  0.51545571
#> GTEX-WYBS-2426-SM-4ONDI            1 -0.2815139 -0.28959629
#> GTEX-12WSK-1926-SM-5LZVK           1  0.3104348 -0.06340276
dds <- DESeq2::DESeqDataSet(ctl_ann, design = ~ ventilator + agony)
#> converting counts to integer mode
dds
#> class: DESeqDataSet 
#> dim: 1663 74 
#> metadata(4): tissue source thanatome version
#> assays(1): counts
#> rownames(1663): ENSG00000237973 ENSG00000187608 ... ENSG00000228986
#>   ENSG00000235649
#> rowData names(1): symbol
#> colnames(74): GTEX-145LS-2326-SM-5TDCY GTEX-1PIEJ-1626-SM-E6CP9 ...
#>   GTEX-1H1CY-1926-SM-9WG7X GTEX-1JN1M-2126-SM-D4P2X
#> colData names(15): group lib_size ... flag_surfactant n_genes

Joint regression and the fraction explained

With method = "regression" the sample’s z profile is regressed jointly on the consensus vectors of the axes. This adds the coefficients and the fraction of the sample’s deviation from the tissue centroid explained by the axes. Classification is the same as with the signature score; what the regression adds is the fraction explained. Over the signature genes it is 8-18 percent in median in GTEx; over the whole transcriptome it is under 1 percent, and it is only computed when the reference is a cohort that carries the whole transcriptome (the example carries the signature genes only, so r2_total is NA here). It is measured against the centroid of the reference tissue, so a sample at the centroid has a fraction near zero whatever its state, and it is larger in fast non-ventilated deaths than in the other two states.

rg <- thanatome_score(ctl, reference = "ovary", method = "regression")
summary(rg$r2_signature)
#>    Min. 1st Qu.  Median    Mean 3rd Qu.    Max. 
#> 0.01142 0.05399 0.10140 0.11991 0.17327 0.34640
tapply(rg$r2_signature, ctl$hardy, median)
#>          0          1          2          3          4 
#> 0.07251323 0.25437280 0.20831607 0.10832928 0.13268921

A decision workflow for including or excluding controls

The natural loop is: score the samples, filter, look at the differential expression or the master-regulator analysis, and filter again. Its weakness is that the last step selects on the outcome: a filter kept because “the DE looks better” is a filter fitted to the result. compare_controls() turns the loop into one pass. The candidate criteria are declared first; each one is run once; every result is compared with the one obtained with all controls and with random subsets of the same size, which are the yardstick for what losing samples does by itself. A criterion whose losses and gains do not exceed those of the random subsets acts through sample size, not through the death axes.

The example carries only the signature genes, so the fraction of DEGs in the axes (frac_deg_in_axes) is close to 1 by construction; with a whole transcriptome it is the quantity of interest. The fits should mirror the real analysis: design takes the covariates of the user’s DE as a formula over colData (for example ~ batch + sex; the group term is added last and tested), and BPPARAM spreads the edgeR fits over workers. The random subsets are drawn before fitting, so with the same set.seed() the result does not depend on the backend.

set.seed(1)
criteria <- list(
    perfused = list(preset = "perfused"),
    no_agony = list(preset = "no_agony")
)
cc <- compare_controls(thanatome_example,
    group = "group", control = "control", criteria = criteria,
    reference = "ovary", n_random = 3)
as.data.frame(cc$summary)
#>   criterion n_controls n_deg lost gained lost_random gained_random   jaccard
#> 1       all         72   851    0      0          NA            NA 1.0000000
#> 2  perfused         39   746  137     32         101            18 0.8086070
#> 3  no_agony         60   808   57     14          34             9 0.9179191
#>   jaccard_random sd_delta_lfc sd_delta_lfc_random frac_deg_in_axes sign_flips
#> 1             NA    0.0000000                  NA        0.9917744          0
#> 2      0.8640553    0.4033215          0.19127997        0.9946381          0
#> 3      0.9500000    0.1715700          0.08210375        0.9913366          0

The same comparison can carry a master-regulator analysis: pass as mra a function that takes the DE table of one run and returns a named vector of regulator activities (a wrapper around viper or NaRnEA); the agreement of each criterion with the full set, and of the random subsets, is added to the summary. The regulators themselves can be annotated with annotate_mra(), which reports how much of each regulon lies in the death axes and in which direction.

sig <- death_signatures("ventilator")
up <- sig$ensembl[sig$direction == "up"][1:30]
regs <- list(
    TF_vent = list(tfmode = setNames(rep(1, 30), up)),
    TF_other = paste0("ENSG0000000", seq_len(40))
)
annotate_mra(c(TF_vent = 3.1, TF_other = 0.2), regs,
    axes = c("ventilator", "agony"))
#> DataFrame with 2 rows and 10 columns
#>     regulator       nes n_targets frac_ventilator direction_ventilator
#>   <character> <numeric> <integer>       <numeric>            <numeric>
#> 1     TF_vent       3.1        30               1                    1
#> 2    TF_other       0.2        40               0                   NA
#>   fisher_padj_ventilator frac_agony direction_agony fisher_padj_agony
#>                <numeric>  <numeric>       <numeric>         <numeric>
#> 1            3.61352e-20   0.333333               1       0.000151473
#> 2            1.00000e+00   0.000000              NA       1.000000000
#>   flag_control_state
#>            <logical>
#> 1               TRUE
#> 2              FALSE

audit_report() writes the whole thing as text for a supplement.

audit_report(sc,
    selection = select_samples(sc, preset = "no_agony"), comparison = cc)
#> thanatome audit report
#> ======================
#> Reference: GTEx ovary; method: signature; 74 samples.
#> States (threshold 0.50): perfused = 39, postmortem_rapid = 22, postmortem_agony = 13.
#> Median position on the ventilator axis 0.37 (IQR -0.03 to 0.92); on the agony axis 0.78 (IQR 0.34 to 1.14).
#> Technical flags: pancreas 1, surfactant 1.
#> Internal check against the Hardy label: AUC ventilator 0.94, agony 0.81; state agreement 0.73.
#> 
#> Selection
#> ---------
#> 60 of 74 samples kept. Excluded by criterion: ventilator = 0, agony = 0, ischemia = 0, state = 13, flags = 2.
#> 
#> Sensitivity of the differential expression to the control subset
#> ----------------------------------------------------------------
#> DEG defined by padj <= 0.05 and |log2FC| >= 1; random subsets of the same size are the yardstick.
#>  criterion n_controls n_deg lost lost_random gained gained_random jaccard
#>        all         72   851    0          NA      0            NA   1.000
#>   perfused         39   746  137         101     32            18   0.809
#>   no_agony         60   808   57          34     14             9   0.918
#>  jaccard_random sd_delta_lfc sd_delta_lfc_random frac_deg_in_axes sign_flips
#>              NA        0.000                  NA            0.992          0
#>           0.864        0.403              0.1913            0.995          0
#>           0.950        0.172              0.0821            0.991          0
#> A criterion whose losses and gains do not exceed those of the random subsets acts through sample size, not through the death axes.
#> 
#> In GTEx v8, no subset of post-mortem controls was closer to surgical or living tissue than the full set except, slightly, the ventilated donors; the package annotates and quantifies, it does not correct death.

Annotating an existing differential-expression table

annotate_de() adds to each gene the axis and direction it falls in, the consensus log fold change and the change in the tumour-versus-control log fold change expected when the control subset moves from non-ventilated to ventilated donors (or from fast to slow deaths), which within GTEx equals the contrast between the two subsets of controls.

sig <- death_signatures("ventilator")
de <- data.frame(
    logFC = c(0.2, 2.5, -1), adj.P.Val = c(0.01, 0.001, 0.04),
    row.names = c(sig$ensembl[1], sig$ensembl[2], "ENSG00000000003")
)
annotate_de(de, axes = c("ventilator", "agony"))
#> annotate_de: 2 genes matched the death signatures
#> DataFrame with 3 rows and 12 columns
#>                     logFC adj.P.Val            gene log2FoldChange      padj
#>                 <numeric> <numeric>     <character>      <numeric> <numeric>
#> ENSG00000166189       0.2     0.010 ENSG00000166189            0.2     0.010
#> ENSG00000172409       2.5     0.001 ENSG00000172409            2.5     0.001
#> ENSG00000000003      -1.0     0.040 ENSG00000000003           -1.0     0.040
#>                 axis_ventilator lfc_consensus_ventilator delta_lfc_ventilator
#>                     <character>                <numeric>            <numeric>
#> ENSG00000166189              up                 0.657379            -0.657379
#> ENSG00000172409              up                 0.641746            -0.641746
#> ENSG00000000003              NA                       NA                   NA
#>                  axis_agony lfc_consensus_agony delta_lfc_agony
#>                 <character>           <numeric>       <numeric>
#> ENSG00000166189          NA                  NA              NA
#> ENSG00000172409          NA                  NA              NA
#> ENSG00000000003          NA                  NA              NA
#>                 sign_depends_on_control
#>                               <logical>
#> ENSG00000166189                    TRUE
#> ENSG00000172409                   FALSE
#> ENSG00000000003                   FALSE

References

Ferreira, Pedro G, Manuel Muñoz-Aguirre, Ferran Reverter, et al. 2018. “The Effects of Death and Post-Mortem Cold Ischemia on Human Tissue Transcriptomes.” Nature Communications 9: 490. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-017-02772-x.
GTEx Consortium. 2020. “The GTEx Consortium Atlas of Genetic Regulatory Effects Across Human Tissues.” Science 369 (6509): 1318–30. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.aaz1776.
Hardy, J A, P Wester, B Winblad, C Gezelius, G Bring, and A Eriksson. 1985. “The Patients Dying After Long Terminal Phase Have Acidotic Brains; Implications for Biochemical Measurements on Autopsy Tissue.” Journal of Neural Transmission 61 (3-4): 253–64. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01251916.
Leek, Jeffrey T, W Evan Johnson, Hilary S Parker, Andrew E Jaffe, and John D Storey. 2012. “The Sva Package for Removing Batch Effects and Other Unwanted Variation in High-Throughput Experiments.” Bioinformatics 28 (6): 882–83. https://doi.org/10.1093/bioinformatics/bts034.
Nieuwenhuis, Tim O, Stephanie Y Yang, Rohan X Verma, et al. 2020. “Consistent RNA Sequencing Contamination in GTEx and Other Data Sets.” Nature Communications 11: 1933. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-020-15821-9.
Pozhitkov, Alexander E, Rafik Neme, Tomislav Domazet-Lošo, et al. 2017. “Tracing the Dynamics of Gene Transcripts After Organismal Death.” Open Biology 7 (1): 160267. https://doi.org/10.1098/rsob.160267.
Risso, Davide, John Ngai, Terence P Speed, and Sandrine Dudoit. 2014. “Normalization of RNA-Seq Data Using Factor Analysis of Control Genes or Samples.” Nature Biotechnology 32: 896–902. https://doi.org/10.1038/nbt.2931.
Wilks, Christopher, Shijie C Zheng, Feng Yong Chen, et al. 2021. “Recount3: Summaries and Queries for Large-Scale RNA-Seq Expression and Splicing.” Genome Biology 22: 323. https://doi.org/10.1186/s13059-021-02533-6.

Session information

sessionInfo()
#> R version 4.6.2 (2026-10-29)
#> Platform: x86_64-pc-linux-gnu
#> Running under: Ubuntu 26.04.1 LTS
#> 
#> Matrix products: default
#> BLAS:   /usr/lib/x86_64-linux-gnu/openblas-pthread/libblas.so.3 
#> LAPACK: /usr/lib/x86_64-linux-gnu/openblas-pthread/libopenblasp-r0.3.32.so;  LAPACK version 3.12.0
#> 
#> locale:
#>  [1] LC_CTYPE=en_US.UTF-8       LC_NUMERIC=C              
#>  [3] LC_TIME=en_US.UTF-8        LC_COLLATE=en_US.UTF-8    
#>  [5] LC_MONETARY=en_US.UTF-8    LC_MESSAGES=en_US.UTF-8   
#>  [7] LC_PAPER=en_US.UTF-8       LC_NAME=C                 
#>  [9] LC_ADDRESS=C               LC_TELEPHONE=C            
#> [11] LC_MEASUREMENT=en_US.UTF-8 LC_IDENTIFICATION=C       
#> 
#> time zone: Etc/UTC
#> tzcode source: system (glibc)
#> 
#> attached base packages:
#> [1] stats4    stats     graphics  grDevices utils     datasets  methods  
#> [8] base     
#> 
#> other attached packages:
#>  [1] thanatome_0.99.0            SummarizedExperiment_1.43.0
#>  [3] Biobase_2.73.2              GenomicRanges_1.65.4       
#>  [5] Seqinfo_1.3.2               IRanges_2.47.5             
#>  [7] S4Vectors_0.51.10           BiocGenerics_0.59.12       
#>  [9] generics_0.1.4              MatrixGenerics_1.25.0      
#> [11] matrixStats_1.5.0           BiocStyle_2.41.0           
#> 
#> loaded via a namespace (and not attached):
#>  [1] sass_0.4.10         SparseArray_1.13.4  DESeq2_1.53.7      
#>  [4] lattice_0.23-1      digest_0.6.39       evaluate_1.0.5     
#>  [7] grid_4.6.2          RColorBrewer_1.1-3  fastmap_1.2.0      
#> [10] jsonlite_2.0.0      Matrix_1.7-6        limma_3.99.4       
#> [13] BiocManager_1.30.27 scales_1.4.0        codetools_0.2-20   
#> [16] jquerylib_0.1.4     abind_1.4-8         cli_3.6.6          
#> [19] rlang_1.3.0         XVector_0.53.0      withr_3.0.3        
#> [22] cachem_1.1.0        DelayedArray_0.39.8 yaml_2.3.12        
#> [25] otel_0.3.0          S4Arrays_1.13.2     parallel_4.6.2     
#> [28] tools_4.6.2         BiocParallel_1.47.0 ggplot2_4.0.3      
#> [31] locfit_1.5-9.12     buildtools_1.0.0    vctrs_0.7.3        
#> [34] R6_2.6.1            lifecycle_1.0.5     edgeR_4.99.12      
#> [37] bslib_0.12.0        gtable_0.3.6        Rcpp_1.1.2         
#> [40] glue_1.8.1          statmod_1.5.2       xfun_0.62          
#> [43] sys_3.4.3           knitr_1.52          farver_2.1.2       
#> [46] htmltools_0.5.9     labeling_0.4.3      rmarkdown_2.32     
#> [49] maketools_1.3.2     compiler_4.6.2      S7_0.2.2